Home    Site Search   Contact Us     Subscribe



Albert Barnes Offers Critical Response to Placement of New "Barnes"

Barnes agrees to talk with fellow Central High School of Philadelphia alum after 61 years of silence, but only on the condition that his remarks remain unedited. This transcript respects his requirement.

By Norman Weinstein
June 19, 2012

Dishonoring the serious wishes of the deceased has long been a Philadelphia tradition, a point we banter among ourselves endlessly, Louis Kahn and I. What could be expected of a city where one “old original Bookbinders” seafood restaurant battled in courtrooms for years with the other Bookbinders claiming the same moniker across the street? Consider my jest a serious accusation. Philadelphia, however many its virtues, has long suffered from an irresponsible mélange of inauthentic histories, a plethora of “old originals” that were anything but. From where I sit in eternity, I have the singular perspective of observing architectural and other city-wide changes in Philadelphia driven by curious notions of blending competing versions of old originals with new fads.


This uneasy toying with styles and eras, intensified by the addition of the new building housing my legacy, strikes me as pathetic and comedic. Your architecture critics have joined with members of that indefinable occupation known as “urban planning” to place my collection – shoe-horn it, really, into a flimsy concept labeled “cultural corridor.” Rather than tally the surface graces and abominations of the building itself, designed by Tod Williams Billie Tsien Architects, that I’ve yet to traverse – Kahn wants his first visit with me, and travel arrangements for us have been repeatedly botched – I wish to address the forced relocation of my art collection, a degradation made possible by spurious “cultural corridor” blather.


The University of Pennsylvania was long a thorn in my side. Only Kahn’s appointment there after my death gave me hope for the institution. But there’s a professor at Penn now, David Brownlee, who reminds me of the original reason for my paranoia about that academic enclave. Through his shameless language regaling the new Barnes Foundation building and Philadelphia’s “reinvigorated” “cultural corridor” that this building is unwittingly an engine of, Brownlee flies in the face of every value I lived for. This is how the man speaks:


David Brownlee, professor of art history at the University of Pennsylvania, says the simple fact of the Barnes’s presence has “enormously intensified the pleasure of walking along the Parkway. It’s reduced the psychological size of the Parkway, and the experience is much more one of continuous architectural excitement.” [Architectural Record, June 2012: “Philly Forward” by Diana Lind]


Here’s context for you non-Philadelphians so you can savor the shallowness of Brownlee’s assertion. “The Parkway,” Benjamin Franklin Parkway to be precise, is Philadelphia’s glory, 1.5 miles designed by Frenchman Jacques Greber and realized in 1917, a not-insignificant historic marker for Paris or Philadelphia. A prevalent urban myth that Brownlee’s interviewer for Architectural Record, Diana Lind, perpetuates, is that the Parkway was Philadelphia’s version of the Champs-Élysées. Maybe for Greber and the marketing hucksters for the city ever since, but not for the rest of us. This is just another witless example of scrambling “old originals.” What the Parkway has always been is the embodiment (on a diagonal dramatizing Emily Dickinson’s “Tell the truth but tell it slant”) of William Penn’s American Quaker romantic capitalist illuminated path.  William Penn statuesquely towers over the Parkway from his perch crowning City Hall’s tower. Penn himself embodied the daunting contradictions of the romantic English gentleman who pined for Philadelphia as “green countrie towne” while capaciously capitalist enough to hunger for Philadelphia as a bustling commercial center. Even though skyscrapers are dwarfing his once uncontested summit, he still is the city’s hero dwelling in the heavens, and along the length and breadth of the Parkway as a roiling contradictory cultural-commercial presence like no other.


The Parkway also operates as a central artery to the city’s heart, a six-lane boulevard linking panoramically City Hall with a carefully choreographed unfolding of Beaux-Arts buildings that include the Free Library of Philadelphia, the Franklin Institute for budding young scientists, the Philadelphia Museum of Art, and the second largest collection of Rodin in the world in a museum designed by Paul Cret. Yet this same cultural panorama includes beyond this urban culture temple complex the looming towers of banking skyscrapers and the rolling green (even if ill-maintained) expanses of Fairmount Park. How does one make this urban “ensemble” cohere is a far deeper query than how do you make art institutions along the Parkway into a vulgar faux-Mecca of art consumption?


You may remember that Cret hired Kahn for the Rodin Museum, cementing their collegial friendship that has prospered from that life to this unbounded life. Cret designed my Lower Merion building, now reduced to a poor stepchild adrift in the suburbs. Since the new Barnes building opened, Cret has been fuming about the coy de- and re-commissioning of our original digs, as well as the inappropriateness of his Rodin Museum in the same goddamned “cultural corridor” as what Kahn tells me appears at a cloudy distance as a “faux-Kahn” building that now wears my name.


But I digress. Back to Brownlee’s experience of the new Barnes and the supposedly new, improved Parkway. Here’s my big query for Brownlee: why would any sane individual want to situate architecture where it would reduce the psychological size of the Parkway? Why wouldn’t architecture be added or modified to increase the psychological size of the Parkway, to magnify the magnificent rhythms of the original Parkway ranging from the baroquely rococo City Hall to the neo-classical Philadelphia Museum of Art? Alas, Brownlee may have answered that question by admitting his ideal Parkway is “one of continuous architectural excitement.” The Parkway was never meant to be one long uninterrupted architectural thrill. Nor should any boulevard in any city be. Cities, like my displays of art in Lower Merion, are essentially dynamic ensembles full of peaks and vales. They refresh us as visitors and dwellers through alternating and unpredictable rhythms stimulating our senses, and then invite repose and meditative reflection upon ever-changing swirls of variegated experiences. The extraordinarily rich ensemble of artistic and cultural institutions lining Philadelphia’s Parkway exists in a broad context of competing versions of history and the present, the messy ensemble Philadelphia is, despite the categorical imperatives of academic planners who love their categories more than street grit under their soles.


Philadelphia has long suffered provincialism, and that was why I had to set up my collection outside of the grip of its provincial enforcers downtown. Provincial types trumpet singleness of vision; they laud it while trumping expansive open-ended pluralism. Hence the notion that the new Barnes building mythically completes Philadelphia’s vision of an American Champs- Élysées. It will share with the Parisian boulevard traffic jams, panhandlers, disoriented elderly tourists in Ponce de Leon searches for an artistic fountain of eternal youth. But I’m not certain that artists, true art lovers, and the curious sans formal schooling, will regularly fill its hallways, or consider it the penultimate destination along Philadelphia’s new Arts Corridor for the Breathlessly Excitable.


The original Barnes Collection was a workshop, a school, a welcome retreat from Philadelphia’s official world of arts and culture. The new Barnes may or may not “work” as an isolated bit of museum architecture, but it has nothing to do with my original structure’s purpose. Where I reside currently knows nothing of “cultural corridors” to empty tourists of their spare change in return for a staged, legally-sanctioned mockery of my original collection along with a contrived fantasy of Paris on the Schuylkill River. There are no superfluous amenities like gift shops or cafes, no oversized parking accommodations where I speak from, no fenestration permitting a darting glance away from a Matisse painting to a view of Parkway traffic. But the light streams and plays exquisitely, surprisingly, on the art that everything that breathes here is.



Norman Weinstein writes about architecture and design for Architectural Record, and is the author of “Words That Build” – an exclusive 21-part series published by – that focuses on the overlooked foundations of architecture: oral and written communication. He consults with architects and engineers interested in communicating more profitably; his webinars are available from ExecSense. He can be reached at


More by Weinstein:


A Meditation on the Beauty of Zaha Hadid's Door Handle

Hadid's design issues a challenge: define beauty by lyrically playing with illusion.


Why "Greatest Hits" Lists by Architecture's Stars Should Be Mocked 
Transferring the musical or cinematic "greatest hits" list mind-set to architecture is deleterious, and here's why.


Celebratory Meditations on SANAA Winning the Pritzker Prize


Op-Ed: Life After Ada: Reassessing the Utility of Architectural Criticism 
Ada Louise Huxtable deserves mucho thanks and praise - but other questions moving us to a new flavor of criticism have to be asked.



Imperfect Health: Probing the Porous Interface between Architecture and Health
A new book and website linked to a recent Canadian Centre for Architecture exhibition offer a healthy tonic countering academically anemic architectural education.


Book Review: Advancing Windswept Design: Pointers from Art Nouveau, Zaha Hadid, and Charles Sowers
New books and installation art highlight breezy refinements in wind-inspired design.


Book Review: Laboratory Architecture for Observing Nature at Play
Books on Luis Barragan's house and BNIM's Omega Center for Sustainable Living reveal how transparently daring designs teach Nature's processes.


Book Review: Tracing a Hidden Track from Adolf Loos as Modernist Architect to Jennifer Post as Modernist Interior Designer
By considering this unlikely couple, we can air out that beleaguered term "architectural minimalism" and trace a trajectory of what might be better identified as "essentialist architecture."


Two Books to Accelerate the Translation of Ideas into Practical Forms
New books on design research and transformational ideas through architectural history have potent practical uses: "The Designer's Guide to Doing Research: Applying Knowledge to Inform Design" Sally Augustin and Cindy Coleman; and "100 Ideas That Changed Architecture" by Richard Weston


Book Review: How to be a Useful Architectural Critic: Alexandra Lange's Perspicacious Primer Points the Way
"Writing about Architecture: Mastering the Language of Buildings and Cities" - use it often and you'll never think of the word "critic" pejoratively again.


Michael Sorkin: Architectural Critic as Scam Scanner and Urban(e) Design Sage
Sorkin's "All Over the Map," a sprawling miscellany of recent essays on buildings and cities, a triumph of enlightened nay-saying and affirmation.


Best Architecture Books of 2011
10 Books Sparking Creative Inspiration Plus Escapist Fare for Financially Fickle Times


Book Review: Pencils that Refuse to Die: Meditations about New Books on Architectural Drawing 
Three recent books dealing with architectural drawing by pencil you need to read: "Eleven Exercises in the Art of Architectural Drawing: Slow Food for the Architect's Imagination" by Marco Frascari; "The Architect's Sketchbook" by Will Jones; and "Robbie Cornelissen: The Capacious Memory" by Lex ter Braak and Edwin Jacobs


Book Review: "One Million Acres & No Zoning": Lars Lerup's Outrageous Encomium to Houston Instructs and Infuriates 
This isn't some dryly academic reconfiguration of trendy urban planning theory. I recommend it for the intrepid.


Book Review: Talkin' 'Bout (Not) My Generation: Uplifting Gen X Architects Showcase Pragmatic Optimism 
In "New York Dozen: Gen X Architects" by architect Michael J. Crosbie, the framing of each architectural firm is extraordinary.


"Frank Lloyd Wright's Guggenheim Museum": Bravura Example of an Architectural Documentary - Wright's Guggenheim Done Right 
A look at great architecture as the product of the dance of the designer's intellect in an architectural film that doesn't miss a beat.


Book Review: A Shout Out for Leers Weinzapfel Associates: "Made to Measure" - Some Meditations on Rejuvenating Campus Architecture


Book Review: Diving into Architecture from Every New Angle: Reading Guillevic's "Geometries" 
Why an obscure book of French poetry in a flashy translation goes to the heart of every architectural practice.


Book Review: "Immaterial World: Transparency in Architecture": Marc Kristal crystallizes increasingly complex notions of transparency with a light touch. 
Although most of the 25 projects discussed are well-known, they take on additional meaning in this sensitively curated selection. 


Book Review: "Visual Planning and the Picuresque" by Nikolaus Pevsner. Edited by Mathew Aitchison 
A rediscovered manuscript unveils a portrait of the famed architectural historian as neglected urban designer. His commitment to the picturesque aesthetic for buildings and towns is as urgently needed as ever.


Book Review: How New Urbanism's Case Triumphs Best Through "The Language of Towns & Cities: A Visual Dictionary" by Dhiru A. Thadani 
Thadani's oversized reference charms, infuriates, and enlightens.


Best Architecture Books of 2010 
Ten books pointing the way to larger professional horizons


Book Review: "Architecture and Beauty: Conversations with Architects about a Troubled Relationship": Yael Reisner exuberantly interviews architects about beauty 
Any of you architects seen Mr. Keats Lately?


Book Review: Shedding Light on Concrete: Tadao Ando: Complete Works 1975-2010 by Philip Jodidio 
Photographic presentation of a poet of light and concrete triumphs over lackluster commentary.


Book Review: Sage Architectural Reflections from Architecture's "Athena": Denise Scott Brown's "Having Words" distills a lifetime of theorizing and practice into practical and succinct guidance for thriving through difficult times 
Brown's occasional papers trace a trenchant trajectory of learning from Las Vegas to learning from everything.


Book Review: Keeping the Architectural Profession Professional: "Architecture from the Outside In: Selected Essays by Robert Gutman" celebrates Gutman's legacy as invaluable outsider
Selected essays by a penetrating sociologist of architecture pose the kinds of tough-minded questions needed now to keep architectural professional on-track.


Book Review: "Design through Dialogue: A Guide for Clients and Architects," by Karen A. Franck and Teresa von Sommaruga Howard 
A helpful communications primer offers case studies of winning collaborations between clients and architects, but as useful as this book proves, it leaves some uncomfortable questions about communication unaddressed.


Twilight Visions: Vintage Surrealist Photography Sheds New Light on Architecture 
An exhibition and book of photographs of Paris between the wars might just be the necessary correctives to the virtual sterility of digital imagery


Best Architecture Books of 2009 
10 crucial volumes from the classic to the iconoclastic


Book Review: "Gunnar Birkerts: Metaphoric Modernist" by Sven Birkerts and Martin Schwartz

A major architect in the history of Modernism finally receives recognition – and sundry asides about why Modernism never exited.


Book Review: "Urban Design for an Urban Century: Placemaking for People," by Lance Jay Brown, David Dixon, and Oliver Gillham 
To the credit of the erudite authors, their sketch of urban design brings levels of political, sociological, and architectural analysis together in a readable synthesis.


Book Review: "Everything Must Move: 15 Years at Rice School of Architecture 1994-2009" 
There’s a Texas flood of architectural ideas that gives ample evidence of an architecture school that unsettles pat assumptions. Who could ask for anything more?


Book Review: A Subversive Book Every Architect Needs: "Architect's Essentials of Negotiation" by Ava J. Abramowitz 
Supposedly architects don't need negotiating skills along with other communication skills because great design "sells itself." How lovely that an AIA legal counsel created this definitive book to shatter that thin myth.


Book Review: A Perspective from One Elevation: "Conversations With Frank Gehry" by Barbara Isenberg

Gehry's conversations offer portraits of an astute listener as well as talker, an architect as aware of his flaws and limitations as of his virtues.


Best Architecture Books of 2008 
10 tomes from the superior to the indispensable


Book Review: You've Got to Draw the Line Somewhere

A review of Drafting Culture: a Social History of Architectural Graphic Standards by George Barnett Johnston


Book Review: "NeoHooDoo: Art for a Forgotten Faith," edited by Franklin Sirmans

Sharpen your pencils - and get ready to do a NeoHooDoo shimmy.


(click on pictures to enlarge)

Photo courtesy Lee Rosenbaum

The new Barnes Foundation Art Education Center, designed by Tod Williams Billie Tsien Architects, and Ellsworth Kelly’s “the Barnes Totem,” recently installed in the OLIN-designed landscape.

Photo courtesy Lee Rosenbaum

View of the transluscent canopy atop the Barnes Foundation building.